Cold Creek Reservoir, constructed in 1943 for irrigation, is a small, spring fed impoundment located in northern Newark Valley on BLM and private land. The Cold Creek complex consists of a main springhead with an outflow stream feeding two lower ponds. The middle pond has been dry in recent years, but the lower pond is considered the actual reservoir for fishing. The public can access the entire reservoir.
View Map- Click Here
- Region
- Eastern
- County
- White Pine
- Type of water
- Lake or Reservoir
Fishing Report
Approximately 50% of the reservoir is covered with a thin layer of ice. The southern half of the reservoir has open water and should be conducive to shoreline angling. Anglers could use nightcrawlers and spinners to catch trout this winter. The fishery is recovering after significant drawdown events.
Cold Creek Reservoir Angler Guide Information
01-30-2026Stocking Updates
| Stocked | Species | Inches | Date Stocked | Year to Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5000 | Tiger Trout | 3.7 | 07-24-2025 | 7024 |
| 2024 | Rainbow Trout | 10 | 04-15-2025 | 2024 |
| 200 | Largemouth Bass | 5.0 | 05-23-2024 | 200 |
| 1002 | Rainbow Trout | 9.0 | 04-23-2024 | 1002 |
| 1517 | Tiger Trout | 9.1 | 05-17-2023 | 1517 |
| 2050 | Rainbow Trout | 8.5 | 05-10-2023 | 2050 |
Pertinent Information
Cold Creek Reservoir covers 14 surface acres and has a maximum depth of 24 feet. Along with a wild, spawning population of rainbow trout, hatchery rainbow trout are stocked annually to augment angling. Largemouth bass and bowcutt trout (rainbow x cutthroat trout hybrid) have been reintroduced in recent years to help control the abundance of nuisance tui chub. It is best fished from mid-spring through summer if the water level is good. Bait such as Power Bait, salmon eggs, and nightcrawlers are most productive when fished off the bottom. Spinners such as Mepps and Panther Martins are popular with many anglers. Nymphs and green or brown wooly buggers are the best choices for fly-fishing. An unimproved boat ramp occurs at the main pond and primitive camping is available nearby. No other facilities are available.